Home News Rockrimmon Library supporters file lawsuit over claims of secrecy, violations

Rockrimmon Library supporters file lawsuit over claims of secrecy, violations

0
Rockrimmon Library supporters file lawsuit over claims of secrecy, violations

Integrity Matters, a government watchdog nonprofit located in Colorado Springs, along with several other plaintiffs, have filed a lawsuit against the Pikes Peak Library District concerning the closure of its Rockrimmon Library branch. The suit, lodged in the 4th Judicial District Court in El Paso County, alleges that the decision to close the library was made “without public notice, meaningful engagement, or required financial analysis.” The Board of Trustees of the library district is accused of violating the state’s open meetings law, breaching statutes governing public libraries, and disregarding the district’s bylaws. Plaintiffs argue that the Board did not act in the best interests of the library district and lacked transparency with the public.

Entitled “We’re not giving up,” activists argue that the decision reflects a lack of fiduciary responsibility and ignores the recommendations of PPLD’s paid consultant. They describe the closure as unjustified, given the library’s high usage, low operational costs, and crucial role in serving the community. However, the library district spokeswoman, Denise Abbott, said the district had not received the legal paperwork by Monday morning. That same day, the district closed due to a snowstorm.

Named plaintiffs include Colorado Springs residents Virginia, Jack, and Trevor Baker, and Svetlana Nudelman, along with COS Reads, a nonprofit emerging from the Save Rockrimmon Library movement, and Westside Watch, a local monitoring group focused on wildfire evacuation plans.

The board of trustees, guided by a new facilities plan that recommended closing some of its 15 branches for cost reasons, voted 5-2 at an Oct. 16 meeting not to renew the Rockrimmon Library’s lease. The library opened in 1989 in northwestern Colorado Springs. Despite receiving support from elected officials and community members, efforts to delay the decision failed, with some critics calling the sudden closure decision an “ambush announcement.”

Pikes Peak Library District’s Chief Librarian and CEO, Teona Shainidze-Krebs, had explained in a previous interview that the closure option arose following numerous public meetings and was focused on financial constraints and the need to provide services across El Paso County. She indicated that mobile book services and kiosks would replace the library services offered by the Rockrimmon branch, which was situated in a leased strip mall location.

On Dec. 4, the Board of Trustees confirmed their decision not to rescind the closing of the Rockrimmon branch by a 5-2 vote. The plaintiffs named in the complaint are the Board of El Paso County Commissioners, the city of Colorado Springs, the Pikes Peak Library District, its Board of Trustees, and Shainidze-Krebs.

The lawsuit seeks a preliminary injunction to stop the closure of the Rockrimmon branch and prevent the landlord from leasing the space to a new tenant. Plaintiffs are asking for a ruling on the claim of violation of Colorado’s Open Meetings Law. If successful, they demand the Board of Trustees approves a one-year lease extension, conducts a comprehensive financial review with community input, and ensures any further decisions comply with the state’s open meeting law and public library directives. The library was open for public use until Nov. 30, with the lease expiring on Dec. 31. The early closure was to allow employees time to move the library’s contents.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here